ProfitShield vs Lifetimely
Lifetimely measures the loss.
ProfitShield blocks it.
Lifetimely is genuinely strong on LTV, cohorts and profit analytics — a different job, done well. But analytics report a money-losing order; they can't stop it. ProfitShield adds real-time flag/block at checkout on top of the same per-order profit math. Same Shopify cost data — nothing to re-import.
14-day free trial · cancel anytime · no re-import
Lifetimely · profit analytics
Measures profit & lifetime value
Lifetimely shines at retention questions: LTV, cohorts, payback and an AI agent that surfaces trends. Profit is one of many lenses. It tells you which orders and cohorts lose money — after they happen.
ProfitShield · analytics + enforcement
Acts on profit at checkout
ProfitShield is purpose-built for one job: per-order true profit, enforced at checkout. It flags or blocks the money-loser the moment it's placed — the thing an analytics suite can't do.
Already on Lifetimely?
There's nothing to re-import.
ProfitShield reads the same Shopify cost data Lifetimely pulls — your product costs already live on your Shopify variants. Connect ProfitShield and your true-profit numbers are there, plus real-time enforcement on top. Switch your profit guardrail in minutes.
Side by side
| Capability | ProfitShield | Lifetimely |
|---|---|---|
| Per-order true profit (COGS, shipping, fees, discounts) | ||
| LTV, cohort & retention analytics | Profit-focused | |
| Syncs product costs from Shopify — no re-import | ||
| Flag unprofitable orders at checkout | ||
| Block unprofitable orders at checkout (real-time) | ||
| Set a profit floor & enforcement mode per store | ||
| Free plan available | ||
| Paid plans start at | $19 / mo | $79 / mo |
Lifetimely pricing & capabilities from its Shopify App Store listing (free plan, paid from $79/mo), checked June 2026. ProfitShield from $19/mo.
Which should you choose?
Stay on Lifetimely if…
- LTV, cohort and retention analytics are your priority, not order-level enforcement.
- You want its AI Profit Agent to surface marketing and retention trends.
- You need a deep, multi-metric analytics suite and the team to use it.
Switch to ProfitShield if…
- You want to prevent loss-making orders at checkout, not just analyze them later.
- You run discounts or free shipping and need a profit floor enforced in real time.
- You want per-order profit and enforcement at a $19/mo paid entry — well below $79.
Keep the cohorts. Add the checkout guardrail.
Per-order true profit plus real-time flag/block at checkout — paid from $19/mo.
14-day free trial · cancel anytime